Huatuchang

Blog Single

Why Forged Parts Are Stronger Than Cast or Machined Parts

Why Forged Parts Are Stronger Than Cast or Machined Parts

Forging makes parts stronger by lining up the grain structure. It also removes problems inside the metal and makes the material better. Forged parts have much higher tensile, fatigue, and yield strength than cast or machined parts. The table below shows how much better they are.

Material Property

Improvement in Forged Parts Compared to Cast/Machined Parts

Tensile Strength

About 26% higher, so parts can handle more pulling force

Fatigue Strength

About 37% higher, so parts last longer when used over and over

Yield Strength

About 44% higher, so parts can take more stress before they change shape for good

Deformation Before Failure

Bigger deformation area, so parts bend more before they break

Bar chart showing percentage improvements in tensile, fatigue, and yield strength for forged parts over cast or machined parts

Forging and Strength

Grain Structure Alignment

Forging changes how metal grains line up inside a part. When a manufacturer forges metal, they use strong force to shape it. This force stretches the grains and lines them up with the part’s shape. The grains follow the curves and bends of the part. This makes a smooth path through the metal. Grain flow gives the part more strength. It also makes it harder for cracks to start or spread.

In open die forging and seamless rolled ring forging, grains stretch in the same direction as the force. This makes the part stronger and tougher. It also helps the part last longer when used many times. For example, forged automotive crankshafts and aerospace turbine blades last longer. This is because the grain flow matches the way stress moves through the part. Forging also makes the grains smaller and more even. This helps stop cracks from growing. Studies show forged titanium alloys with more grain alignment last longer. Smaller, even grains spread out stress. This keeps cracks from starting at the grain edges.

Tip: Forged parts stop cracks from growing better than cast or machined parts. The grain flow acts like a wall. This makes forged parts great for jobs with lots of stress or heavy loads.

Material Integrity

Forging does more than line up grains. It also makes the metal’s inside structure better. The process heats and squeezes the metal. This removes empty spaces and closes tiny holes inside. The part becomes denser and stronger. Forging also spreads out alloying elements. This makes the metal more even.

Casting often leaves defects because the metal cools unevenly. These defects can make the part weak and easy to break. Machining does not change the inside of the metal. So, any defects in the starting material stay in the finished part. Forging fixes these problems. It makes a part that is stronger and more reliable.

Property

鍛造

Casting

Machining

Internal Defects

Eliminated or minimized

Common (porosity, cracks)

Remain from original material

Grain Flow

Aligned with part shape

Random

Cut through by machining

Mechanical Strength

High

Lower

Depends on starting material

Fatigue Life

Long

Shorter

Shorter

Forging also makes parts bend more before breaking. The lined-up grains and dense structure help the part bend without snapping. This makes forged parts safer and more dependable in important uses, like cars, airplanes, and big machines.

Forged Parts vs. Cast and Machined

Grain Flow vs. Grain Ends

Forging changes how grains form inside metal. When forging is used, grains stretch and follow the part’s shape. This grain flow makes the part much stronger. In cast or machined parts, grains do not line up. Instead, grains end in random spots. These grain ends can be weak, especially under high stress.

Casting cools metal unevenly. Grains grow in many directions and sizes. The ends of grains meet at sharp angles. Cracks can start at these grain ends under pressure. In cast steels, ferrite bands and needle-like plates form at grain edges. These do not always cause cracks in normal use. But with extreme bending or high stress, cracks can start there. Elements like copper and tin can gather at grain edges. This makes failure more likely.

Forged parts do not have these problems. Forging lines up the grains. Stress moves smoothly through the part. Forged products are less likely to crack or break. The part has the same properties everywhere. This is important for safety and performance.

Defects and Reliability

Casting leaves behind empty spaces and impurities. These include air bubbles, shrinkage, and porosity. These flaws make the part weaker and less reliable. Machined parts keep any defects from the starting material. Forging uses heat and pressure to squeeze out these voids. It also lines up the grains. This makes the metal denser and stronger.

Here is a table comparing the impact of defects in casting and forging:

Property

Casting Impact

Forging Impact

Defects

Higher porosity (2-5%), internal flaws, shrinkage defects

Low porosity and cracks due to compressive grain alignment

Strength

Moderate tensile strength, prone to weaknesses from defects

Higher tensile strength and impact resistance due to refined grain structure

Durability

More vulnerable to stress cracks and fatigue failure

Excellent resistance to fatigue, wear, and thermal stresses

Suitability

Complex shapes but less reliable under high stress

Superior reliability for critical applications

Forged parts are much more reliable. They fail less and last longer, even under high stress. In important jobs like oil and gas fracking, forged products cut down on repairs and downtime. Cast parts have more porosity and crack more often. Machined parts do not change the inside, so they are not as reliable as forged parts.

Mechanical Properties

Forging and machining have big differences in strength and toughness. Forged parts have tighter grains and fewer flaws inside. This gives them higher strength and better performance under repeated loads. Data shows forged parts have 37% higher fatigue strength than cast parts. They can last up to six times longer before failing. Tensile strength is about 26% higher in forged parts. This lets them handle more force without breaking. Yield strength is also much higher in forged parts than in cast iron.

Looking closer at the inside shows why. Forging makes grains smaller and more even. This boosts strength and toughness. Cast parts have bigger, uneven grains and more flaws. These lower their strength and toughness. Machined parts only change the outside. The inside stays the same as the starting material.

The most common ways cast and machined parts fail are gas porosity, shrinkage, and cracks. These flaws make parts break or wear out faster. Forging removes many of these risks by making the inside better. Forged parts are more durable and resist impacts better.

Note: Forged parts are lighter, stronger, and last longer than cast or machined parts. This makes them the best choice for high stress and safety jobs, like racing wheels, military vehicles, and heavy machines.

Forging, compared to machining and casting, gives unmatched strength and reliability. The lined-up grains, dense structure, and fewer flaws give forged parts a big advantage when failure is not an option.

Advantages of Forging

Real-World Applications

Forging has many real-life benefits. It makes parts lighter and stronger. Forged parts are also more dependable. Many companies pick forging for important jobs. They want parts that last and work well under stress.

  • Automotive and new energy vehicles use forging for drivetrain parts. These parts must be strong and not break.

  • Electric bicycles and motorcycles use forging for frames and gears.

  • Engineering and mining machines need forged parts for hard work. These machines deal with heavy loads and rough use.

  • Agricultural, forestry, and recycling equipment use forging for tools and moving parts.

  • Electrical products and motors use forging to help them last longer.

  • Hardware tools and fasteners made by forging do not break easily.

Forging gives better metallurgical properties. It also makes production faster and costs less. Forged parts resist wear and corrosion better. These things make forging the best for tough jobs.

Longevity and Safety

Forging helps parts last longer and stay safe. The process lines up the grain structure with the part’s shape. This gives more strength and helps parts take shocks and pressure. Studies show forged parts have up to 37% higher fatigue strength. They can last six times longer than cast or machined parts.

Product/Component Type

Reason Forging is Chosen

Airplane Landing Gears

Needs to be strong and reliable during landing

Automotive Drivetrain Components

Needs extra strength for rods, axles, and driveshafts

Tools (hammers, wrenches)

Needs to last and work well under hard use

Oil and Gas Industry Components

Needs to be safe in high-pressure places

Sports Equipment

Needs to be strong and reliable

Forging also cuts down on waste and saves energy. Forged parts do not need to be replaced as often. This helps the environment. Many industries trust forging for important parts. Forging gives the best durability and reliability.

Forging makes parts stronger by changing the grain structure. It also gets rid of defects and makes the material better.

FAQ

What makes forged parts stronger than cast or machined parts?

Forged parts have grains that follow the shape of the part. This grain flow increases strength and helps stop cracks from spreading.

Can forged parts replace cast or machined parts in all uses?

Forged parts work best for high-stress jobs. Some complex shapes or low-stress parts may still use casting or machining.

Why do industries choose forging for safety-critical components?

Industries pick forging because it gives higher strength, better reliability, and longer life. Forged parts help prevent failures in important machines and vehicles.

コメントを残す

メールアドレスが公開されることはありません。 が付いている欄は必須項目です